Ally Moran and Jack Ruiz are starting their first year in college and are looking for peace and quiet for the first time in their relationship... However, it may be too much to hope for. First, Ally's long-lost father shows up, making her question everything she thought she knew about her past. Meanwhile, Rémy Giles and the mysterious Mina have accompanied Ally home from France so they can try to figure out what the newest prophecy could possibly mean. Is Ally the next Oracle? And if all this weren't enough, Ally fears she is being stalked, and she appears to have a secret admirer who is sending her creepy personal messages in the college newspaper. However, no one else has seen this "supposed" stalker, so she fears she may be going crazy. As Jack and Remy fight to keep Ally safe against the looming danger, Ally begins to fear for the one thing she can't bear to lose...her sanity.