What happens when the man you've fantasized about for almost a decade reappears in your small town? For Oliver Flaherty, it's the inability to formulate coherent sentences, utterly humiliating behavior, and loads of nausea. Sam Anderson has finally returned, with his sculpted biceps, rock-hard abs, and supermodel DNA. Oliver can't cope. But he has to because he's a professional. Sam is back for one reason only: to sell his aunt's house. But the Realtor hired by her trust is the same person who rejected him all those years ago. Except, had Oliver really turned him down or had Sam read the entire situation wrong? He can't recall now because there's still a sizzle in the air when Oliver is around. Between a handful of mishaps, decades of accumulated clutter, and enough tension to light up the night sky, Sam and Oliver will have to decide if the spark between them is enough to power through a second chance at a first love.